In the fast-paced world of startups, mentoring stands out as a pillar of guidance and support. By exploring mentoring strategies in more detail, we learn that mentoring is an ever-changing process full of challenges and opportunities for growth.  

We sat down with David Gjerde, the co-founder and COO of Acterio, to learn more about the importance of mentoring in the success of startups within incubators and accelerators. 

‍

The startup puzzle: navigating the unknown

In the startup world, a big challenge most teams face is missing certain experiences or knowledge. Whether you're an aspiring entrepreneur delving into the world of e-commerce, or a tech lover stepping into ed-tech, starting a business is a lot to take on. Without the proper guidance, navigating these waters yourself can be quite daunting. As David puts it, "The hardest part is not knowing what you need to know."

Cracking the startup code becomes a lot easier with mentorship. David emphasizes that mentors, with their experience and network, provide a shortcut, eliminating uncertainties and helping avoid common pitfalls.  However, mentors come with their own set of personal preferences that can influence the direction and advice they provide. It’s essential to recognize these preferences early in the mentorship relationship. 

Picking the right mentors is a serious task for incubators and accelerators. Incubators look at what they've got internally and figure out where they need extra help. Startups, on the other hand, must comprehend the mentors' expertise and align it with their competence gaps, moving beyond the mentors' personal preferences. It is important to find that sweet spot where mentor and startup interests align.

‍

The power of mentoring in startups

At the heart of every successful startup, you'll often find a mentor – someone whose wisdom and experience become the guiding light through the murky waters of business challenges, from strategic puzzles to unavoidable legal snags.

Good mentoring brings real, palpable benefits that save precious time for startups. Mentors can open doors by connecting startups with the right folks, potential clients, and early cheerleaders – thus building trust and smoothing the path for key tasks like research and making those crucial sales calls. They make the startup journey smoother and more efficient, helping to sidestep pitfalls before they even appear. Mentorship can offer laser-focused help to tackle immediate hurdles, but its benefits can also stretch far into the future, adapting to the startup's changing needs. 

That said, it's not a one-size-fits-all scenario. Not every mentor-mentee relationship evolves into a long-term partnership or sees the mentor stepping into an advisory or investment role. Sometimes, a mentor's role is to provide crucial support at a pivotal moment, without necessarily embedding themselves in the startup's ongoing narrative.

The truth is, while mentors who consistently add value can become vital to a startup, this isn't the endgame for all mentoring relationships. Yes, for some, moving from mentor to advisor or even investor is a natural and beneficial progression. This deeper involvement can offer strategic insights and a vested interest in the startup's success, but effective mentoring comes in many shapes and sizes. It's not solely about formal titles or financial stakes. The essence of a great mentorship lies in its flexibility and the myriad ways it can positively influence a startup's journey, each unique and invaluable in its own right.

‍

Navigating the challenges of startup mentoring

In startup mentoring, some challenges can make programs less effective. Understanding these challenges is vital for creating an environment where mentorship can truly flourish. 

‍

Engaging mentors effectively

One significant challenge revolves around engaging mentors effectively. Mentors join these programs voluntarily, making their involvement a critical factor. However, many mentors may only participate in a few calls or attend a demo day, falling short of maintaining continuous engagement.

"The hardest people to engage in a program and in a startup ecosystem are the mentors, and that's because they are there of their own free will," notes David. The lack of sustained involvement is tricky as mentors may offer valuable insights during sessions, but ensuring these insights are implemented throughout the program becomes a challenge.

‍

Mismatch in mentor's desire for ongoing involvement

Another issue is the mismatch between a mentor's desire for ongoing involvement and the limited opportunities provided. While many mentors express interest in following startups from the selection process through the program and beyond, the current framework often fails to facilitate this extended engagement.

David uses the analogy of horse racing to illustrate the point. Mentors, like race enthusiasts, want to follow their chosen "horse" (startup) from training (selection process) through the race (demo day) and beyond. The absence of mechanisms to track post-program progress adds to the difficulty of maintaining mentor interest and involvement.

‍

Challenges in perceiving tangible results

If mentors are not able to see how their advice and insights are applied and lead to successful outcomes, it can be difficult for them to justify the investment of their time in future mentoring endeavors.

To ensure mentors remain engaged and feel their contributions are worthwhile, it's crucial to integrate their involvement deeply with the startup's progress. This means creating opportunities for mentors to see firsthand how their advice positively affects the startup's operations and growth. Without such visibility, mentors might struggle to see the value in dedicating their efforts to mentoring, which could weaken the impact of mentoring programs.

Addressing these issues is vital for fostering a mentoring atmosphere that encourages ongoing participation and yields benefits for both mentors and startups. The solution involves crafting approaches that increase mentor participation, offer ongoing feedback, and connect the dots between the mentoring provided and the startup's continued achievements.

‍

Strategies for improving mentoring quality

How can we elevate the effectiveness of mentoring?

‍

Active mentor participation in startup selection

A strategic approach involves integrating mentors more deeply into the selection process. By doing so, mentors become integral to deciding which startups are admitted into the program, ensuring a stronger alignment of interests and expertise from the outset.

‍

Sustaining mentor engagement

To maintain mentor interest and involvement, it's crucial to establish a system of regular updates. This ensures mentors are continuously informed about the progress and impacts of the startups they mentor. Showcasing tangible results of their guidance not only validates the mentor's contributions but also rekindles their original motivation for participating.

‍

Monitoring long-term achievements

While inviting mentors to demo days is common, providing them with ongoing updates on the startups' post-program performance can deepen their commitment. This visibility into sustained success reinforces the value and impact of their mentorship.

‍

Soliciting mentor feedback for program enhancement

Engaging mentors in the post-program feedback process empowers them to contribute to the program's evolution. Their insights can help identify and address gaps, enhancing the program's effectiveness. Mentors who see their suggestions implemented are also more likely to remain involved, eager to witness the fruits of their contributions.

‍

Facilitate targeted engagements between mentors and startups

The essence of structured mentorship programs lies in their ability to facilitate targeted and meaningful engagements between mentors and startups. It's not just about structuring the mentorship itself but also about refining the process of matching mentors with startups. Ensuring a compatible match is crucial, as it lays the foundation for productive relationships that extend beyond the program's duration.

‍

Varied methods for facilitating connections

The design of mentorship programs plays a significant role in how mentors and startups connect. Alternating the responsibility for initiating meetings—sometimes placing it on startups, other times on mentors—promotes a dynamic interaction. This flexibility encourages mentors to proactively seek engagements with startups, fostering a more involved and reciprocal relationship.

‍

Attracting and retaining high-quality mentors

Within the broader scope of enhancing mentorship programs, a critical aspect to consider is the dual focus on attracting and retaining high-quality mentors. This process is integral to the overall success and sustainability of these programs.

‍

Attracting and retaining high-quality mentors

Within the broader scope of enhancing mentorship programs, a critical aspect to consider is the dual focus on attracting and retaining high-quality mentors. This process is integral to the overall success and sustainability of these programs.

‍

Attraction through a clear value proposition

The first step involves clearly defining what mentors stand to gain by participating. For seasoned professionals who have shifted from the fast-paced startup environment to corporate roles, re-engaging with the startup world can offer a refreshing return to dynamism and innovation. It's crucial to identify and communicate the specific benefits and opportunities that align with their interests and motivations. 

Whether it’s offering insights into the latest industry trends or the chance to impact emerging startups significantly, understanding what drives potential mentors is key. Highlighting the opportunity for mentors with specific industry expertise to immerse themselves in relevant startup scenes or to contribute actively to the startup ecosystem can make the mentorship more attractive.

‍

Retention through engagement

Once mentors are on board, keeping them engaged becomes the next challenge. This involves embedding them more deeply into the program's processes, such as involving them in the selection of startups or providing them with regular updates on the progress of the enterprises they assist. 

‍

Strategies for sustained involvement

Addressing the challenges of mentor retention requires a focus on building personal relationships and showing appreciation for their contributions. Actively involving mentors in strategic discussions and decision-making processes can help counteract potential disengagement due to external factors, such as time constraints.

Incorporating these strategies into the mentorship program structure enriches the mentorship experience for mentors and startups and bolsters the program's effectiveness. This integrated approach ensures that mentorship remains a dynamic and mutually beneficial component of the startup ecosystem, contributing to its vibrancy and growth.

‍

Engaging incubator and accelerator founders

Creating a strong bond between founders and mentors is extremely important for the success of startup programs. These connections could be the key resource that helps propel a start-up along its journey. 

According to David, here are  simple ways the founders can facilitate a strong connection with their mentor.

‍

Preparing well for mentor meetings

Founders should be ready when they meet with mentors. This means understanding the mentor’s field of expertise and tailoring questions to match. How founders approach the meetings is also key in forming a strong relationship. Founders should see mentors as helpful partners they can bounce ideas off, rather than the answer key to specific questions.

‍

Keeping the connection going

Founders can keep mentors engaged by suggesting further contact after the official sessions. Letting mentors know that founders want to stay connected helps mentors feel that they are a more integral part of the process, whether or not they offer more guidance in the future. 

‍

Setting clear expectations

Clear communication is key to a fruitful relationship. Founders should have a clear goal in mind for each mentoring session, and should properly communicate to the mentor what they hope to learn in their sessions together. 

So, making sure mentors stay engaged involves good communication, staying connected, understanding each other's expectations, and using tools that make things easier. This helps build a supportive and successful environment for startups in incubators and accelerators.

‍

Conclusion

Helping startups succeed in incubators and accelerators is all about creating a friendly and helpful community. When mentors and startups actively support each other and collaborate, sharing challenges and resources, everyone does better. By following these simple principles, we can build a strong foundation for success in the world of startup support.